Automatic: These mimic hand-powered pumps, but they do the pumping for you. They’re convenient and easy to use, but they run on batteries (either rechargeable or disposable), which— needless to say—can be annoying if the power runs out mid-session. Many automatic pumps will display the amount of pressure being exerted, but their quick-release valve (if they have one) may be electronic rather than manual, which would become a safety issue if the pump was to die during use.
Hydro pump: Rather than pulling air out of the cylinder to create pressure, these pumps pull water out of the cylinder. Naturally, this means that you have to fill the pump with water to use it, so these are easiest to use in the shower or bathtub, which can be inconvenient if you’d rather pump in bed or elsewhere. However, some people find water pumps more comfortable than air-based kinds.
The Best Penis Pump for Beginners: Blush
With its basic shape and no-nonsense design, this vacuum pump is ideal for beginners who are pump-curious. For safety’s sake, especially if this is your first time, it’s a good idea to get a pump with a PSI gauge, like this one has, so you know exactly how much pressure is being exerted—and can learn what feels best for you. This pump also has a quick-release valve, so if the sensation gets to be too much, you can end your pumping session in a hurry.
PROS: Comfortable pistol grip; pressure gauge for safety; quick-release valve; can swap out tube for tubes of different sizes (sold separately) if desired
CONS: N/A
The Best Air Penis Pump: LA Pump
LA Pump’s products are considered top-of-the-line, because they’re designed with safety, comfort, and effectiveness in mind, unlike cheaper pumps. This kit contains a brass hand pump, featuring an air pressure gauge and a quick-release button, which connects to an acrylic cylinder. It’s the smartest choice if you want a pump you can use regularly over a long period of time, or if you just want the best of the best from the jump.
PROS: Cylinder base is shaped for comfort and to hold a better seal; pressure gauge for safety; quick-release valve; can swap out tube for tubes of different sizes (sold separately) if desired
CONS: Expensive
The Best Water Penis Pump: Bathmate
Bathmate products are meant to be used in the shower or bath, and they use water in lieu of air to create suction. Water pumping can be more comfortable than air pumping for some users, but there’s no gauge on Bathmate pumps to help you stay within a safe pressure zone, so they’re not as beginner-friendly. You’ll need to pay close attention for any pain, tingling, numbness, or other danger signs.
PROS: Comfortable base; hydro pump mechanism may be more comfortable than other types of pumps for some users; impact-tested to ensure durability
CONS: Expensive; no pressure gauge for safety; heavy; must be used in the bath/shower to prevent spillage/mess
The Best Automatic Penis Pump: CalExotics
Automatic pumps are a good choice if you don’t have the hand strength to use a manual pump, or if you just prefer to see the pressure displayed in precise tenths-of-a-PSI. The LCD readout and controls let you see how much pressure your dick is under at any given moment, and even set a pressure limit for the device, making it easier to stay within a safe and comfortable range.